Joshua Vaughn works for Alabama Trucking as Director of Advocacy and Marketing. As an 11-year veteran of the Business Council of Alabama, Vaughn played a pivotal role in communicating with and advocating for Alabama’s diverse business community. Vaughn has been with Alabama Trucking since 2023 and been instrumental in developing and shaping Alabama Trucking’s public relations and advocacy efforts. He can be reached at jvaughn@alabamatrucking.org

Share

A road sign only works if the driver behind the wheel can read it. That’s the whole argument, and it’s a hard one to beat.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is expected to publish a proposed rule as soon as this month that would make failing an English-proficiency check an automatic out-of-service violation, not a warning, not a note in a file, but an actual “you’re not moving this truck” order. It’s a small change on paper. It is not a small change on the highway.

What the Rule Would Actually Do

Right now, 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2) requires commercial drivers to speak enough English to talk to the public, read traffic signs, answer an officer’s questions, and fill out paperwork. That’s been on the books a long time. What’s changed is the enforcement muscle behind it.

This new FMCSA rulemaking would lock that enforcement into the actual regulation instead of leaving it to CVSA’s criteria.

CVSA treated non-compliance as an out-of-service violation starting in 2005, then dropped it in 2015. President Trump’s April 2025 executive order and a DOT enforcement push brought it roaring back, and CVSA reinstated the out-of-service order in May 2025. This new FMCSA rulemaking, submitted to the White House’s Office of Management and Budget on June 24, would lock that enforcement into the actual regulation instead of leaving it to CVSA’s criteria.

Alabama Already Wrote This Rule Into State Law

Here’s the thing: Alabama isn’t waiting on Washington. Governor Kay Ivey signed the Highway Safety and Fairness Act this spring, requiring every CDL holder operating in this state to prove English proficiency and valid work authorization. Since January 2025, ALEA’s Motor Carrier Safety Unit has issued 548 English-proficiency violations and referred more than 555 drivers to ICE for status checks. Alabama’s 2025 commercial vehicle fatality count, 106, was the lowest since 2021.

Alabama got there first. If FMCSA follows through this month, the rest of the country will finally be driving the same road Alabama troopers have been patrolling for a while now.